Sunday, August 09, 2020

Pretty Ugly

 

A pandemic, Alan Freeman writes, allows us to see our leaders' true colours:

In the U.S., President Donald Trump downplays the surging death toll of the pandemic, but sees it as a great opportunity to muse about delaying the November election he now seems sure to lose. In the U.K., Prime Minister Boris Johnson uses the pandemic diversion to stuff the House of Lords with his cronies, including his brother, the son of a Russian oligarch and members of the Labour Party who backed Brexit. In Canada, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau figures the pandemic is a great time to give those neat guys at WE Charity a $1-billion contract without bothering to look at alternatives.

Such is also the case with Alberta's premier, Jason Kenney:

This week, it emerged that the government of Jason Kenney had agreed to basically scrap this year’s environmental monitoring of water flowing downstream of the province’s oilsands facilities along the main branch of the Athabasca River. No need for field studies on wetlands, fish or insects. No more pilot project on the risks posed by tailings ponds. No study of water quality in response to concerns about environmental degradation at Wood Buffalo National Park, a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

Kenney's decision will make Alberta's oilmen happy. But it's not good news for the other inhabitants of the planet. And it's part of a pattern:

In the spring, Alberta’s energy regulator suspended environmental reporting requirements for the oilsands producers. Requirements to monitor ground and surface water were gone. Testing for methane was suspended. Air quality testing was reduced. A spokesman said the suspensions are likely to stay in place as long as COVID-19-related rules are around.

Interesting that this is the same province that tripped over itself to make sure that its beef-processing plants kept operating, even in the wake of a massive outbreak of COVID-19 among workers at Cargill. Yet these same geniuses somehow couldn’t figure out a way to make water-quality testing safe on a remote northern river. Are they afraid of catching the coronavirus from a duck?

In addition to shutting down environmental monitoring of the oilsands, with Ottawa’s approval, the Kenney government has also decided to revive another dinosaur industry — coal mining. In June, decades-old protections that stopped open-pit mines in parts of the Rocky Mountains and the foothills were rescinded, causing consternation among Albertans anxious to protect the environment. Kenney is also effectively banking on Trump’s re-election as he pours billions into the Keystone XL pipeline that Joe Biden has vowed to stop.

Kenney is hellbent on exploiting the oilsands. But he's moving in the wrong direction:

Last month, Total, the French oil company, dramatically announced plans to write off US$7 billion worth of Alberta oilsands investments, saying they were “stranded assets” with no future because of global carbon-reduction targets and high production costs. Total joined a long list of international investors, including Deutsche Bank, HSBC and BlackRock that have blacklisted the oilsands.

Instead of regretting the decision and explaining what the province is doing to make the sector more climate-friendly, Alberta Energy Minister Sonya Savage decided to lash out, calling Total’s decision “highly hypocritical.” She then went on to make the gobsmacking argument that international energy firms should actually increase their investments in Alberta, rather than pull out. That’s because Alberta is an ethical democracy and “a stable, reliable supply of energy,” she argued, noting that Total was still investing in Myanmar, Nigeria and Russia, presumably a bad idea because of their poor human rights records.

In most cases, when a leader reveals his or her true colours, those colours look pretty ugly.

Image: Al-Qualem Press-WordPress.com

12 comments:

the salamander said...

.. we really don't have Alberta 'oilmen' Owen.. nor do 'we' (Canadians) have an 'oil patch'

That reality is rooted in 97% of Canada's 'vast oil reserves' are actually a black granular substance called Bitumen.. which is now steamed 'in situ' mainly.. for export to somewhere ville.. we just aint sure where somewhere is

It high in sulphur.. and must be diluted with already refined diluent.. thus the resulting slurry is called 'dilbit' .. in she goes.. into pipelines.. supposedly this 'drives Canada's economy' ... the highly prized diluent is recovered.. and as so, is an important part of Western Canadian Select'.. pricing.. which aint West Texas Intermediate light sweet or Brent 'oil'and never will be 'benchmark'.. its 'dilbit' .. like ground hamburger is to sirloin .. discount ?? What discount.. ??

Owen Gray said...

The bottom line is that dilbit is pretty ugly, sal. And it produces ugly consequences. Generally speaking, almost everything seems uglier these days.

the salamander said...

.. the solution is rather simple.. Owen
The Navajo.. and the Hopi simply say
'Walk In Beauty' ..

Owen Gray said...

North America's native people have always understood the natural order of things, sal. Unfortunately, our movers and shakers have declared that they are "backward." Just who has things backward?

jrkrideau said...

Kenney government has also decided to revive another dinosaur industry — coal mining.

I doubt if this will be a problem. Coal seems to be going the way of the dinosaurs. Coal companies in the US are declaring bankruptcy, a promised massive coal development in Ontarioso far seems to consist of one yellow grader that is moved occasionally to show there is life in the project and so on.

What it does seem to indicate is that Kenny and his cabinet are lumbering along leading the dinosaur extinction. I do not think that they have grasped that the days of easy oil money is over.

Owen Gray said...

Your last sentence hits the nail on its head, jrk. Put simply, Kenney and his acolytes don't understand what's going on.

Anonymous said...

Owen, Alberta's Energy Minister is appropriately named "Savage".

RG

The Disaffected Lib said...

North American indigenous nations appreciated the value and importance of bitumen. They used it as a source of pitch to waterproof their birchbark canoes. We also have a use for it - asphalt. If you don't have canoes and don't need roads you can also use it as a great place to store sabre-tooth tigers. Ask the folks at Le Brea.

Mark Carney, during his tenure as governor of the Bank of England, repeatedly warned us that the Tar Sands were a "stranded asset." As the financial sector and the insurance giants pulled up stakes and abandoned Athabasca our governments, federal and provincial, jumped in to forestall collapse. Both Kenney and Trudeau threw billions into pipeline projects the private sector wouldn't touch. That's insanity.

As for coal, we're still pushing metallurgical coal but the market seems to be contracting for thermal (electrical) coal. I read today that India is clearing forests to open 40 new coal fields. Another rightwing authoritarian, Modi.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/aug/08/india-prime-minister-narendra-modi-plans-to-fell-ancient-forest-to-create-40-new-coal-fields

Burning that candle from both ends, Owen, faster with each passing day.

Owen Gray said...

The name couldn't be more appropriate, RG.

Owen Gray said...

Thanks for the link, Mound. This is insanity. We have eyes. But so many of us cannot see.

jrkrideau said...

Note in my earlier post (Ontario) should have read (Australia). I have no idea how I did that. I need a copy editor.

jrkrideau said...

@ The Disaffected Liberal.

The proposed coal development that I have relocated to Australia is/was an Adani group project. So much for it now.