Saturday, May 27, 2017

The Empty Headed Are In Charge

Michael Gerson used to write speeches for George W. Bush. He considers himself a conservative. But he is deeply disturbed about what has happened to conservatism in the era of Donald Trump. He writes:

To many observers on the left, the initial embrace of Seth Rich conspiracy theories by conservative media figures was merely a confirmation of the right’s deformed soul. But for those of us who remember that Rush Limbaugh and Sean Hannity were once relatively mainstream Reaganites, their extended vacation in the fever swamps is even more disturbing. If once you knew better, the indictment is deeper.

The cruel exploitation of the memory of Rich, a Democratic National Committee staffer who was murdered last summer, was horrifying and clarifying. The Hannity right, without evidence, accused Rich rather than the Russians of leaking damaging DNC emails. In doing so, it has proved its willingness to credit anything — no matter how obviously deceptive or toxic — to defend Donald Trump and harm his opponents. Even if it means becoming a megaphone for Russian influence.

Gerson believes that the Conservative Mind is diseased: The glaring symptom of the disease is the lack of common decency:

This failure of decency is also politically symbolic. Who is the politician who legitimized conspiracy thinking at the highest level? Who raised the possibility that Ted Cruz’s father might have been involved in the assassination of John F. Kennedy? Who hinted that Hillary Clinton might have been involved in the death of Vince Foster, or that unnamed liberals might have killed Justice Antonin Scalia? Who not only questioned President Obama’s birth certificate, but raised the prospect of the murder of a Hawaiian state official in a cover-up? “How amazing,” Trump tweeted in 2013, “the State Health Director who verified copies of Obama’s ‘birth certificate’ died in plane crash today. All others lived.”

We have a president charged with maintaining public health who asserts that the vaccination schedule is a dangerous scam of greedy doctors. We have a president charged with representing all Americans who has falsely accused thousands of Muslims of celebrating in the streets following the 9/11 attacks.

Gerson asserts that Trump is doing more harm than Hillary Clinton ever would have done:

Trump is doing a kind of harm beyond anything Clinton could have done. He is changing the party’s most basic moral and political orientations. He is shaping conservatism in his image, and ensuring an eventual defeat more complete, and an eventual exile more prolonged, than Democrats could have dreamed.

The conservative mind, in some very visible cases, has become diseased. The movement has been seized by a kind of discrediting madness, in which conspiracy delusions figure prominently. Institutions and individuals that once served an important ideological role, providing a balance to media bias, are discrediting themselves in crucial ways. With the blessings of a president, they have abandoned the normal constraints of reason and compassion. They have allowed political polarization to reach their hearts, and harden them. They have allowed polarization to dominate their minds, and empty them.

The empty headed -- not the wooden headed -- are in charge.


Steve said...

While the Seth Rich story is weaker than "truthers" or Lone Gunman devotees narrative, it still has some unanswered questions, and certainly is not much weaker than the Russians stole the election gospel.

The fact that we are lied to from birth about the most important things in the world makes it easy for conspiracy theory about everything seem realistic.

Owen Gray said...

But it's our responsibility as citizens, Steve, to separate truth from fiction.

Steve said...

Owen as everyday citizens what tool should we use to beat the truth out of fiction? Should we buy time on Iranian centrifuges, or go on ebay and buy up surplus Iraq portable weapons labs?
Just what do we do to separate truth from fiction?

the salamander said...

.. teach.. your children well ..
Not possible when you can't or won't even reason with yourself ..
When you are completely lacking in any shred of decency or morality

This is the age of the diseased like Alex Jones.. profiting from what?
The persecution and ongoing emotional assault
upon the parents of murdered children at Sandy Hook ?
Inciting ignorant buffoons to attack & insult such horribly traumatized parents
the family, friends & associates of the dead.. or the survivors
not to mention desecrating the memory of the dead,
& spitting on the lives of the survivors..

Somewhere in such a diseased & distorted matrix are the malignants ie Trumps & Hannitys et al
There really are not words.. or a lexicon that can handle or describe such poison..

I have a background working with the young survivors
the social rejects and victims of such toxic scumbags
And I may tend to get quite emotional on the matter
so I try to mask, hide or bag much of my disgust, anger.. and horror
These freaks and creeps are not normal, healthy or responsible

Its a wonderful article Owen, very much appreciated .. thank you
and refreshing to read such insight and courageous opinion
We need thousands more .. very much like it ..

Owen Gray said...

We start by discovering the facts, Steve -- not by denying them. For instance, we research the data and discover that the planet is warming.

Owen Gray said...

Gerson and I are on opposite sides of the political spectrum, salamander. But he has the courage to diagnose what has gone wrong on his side. I respect that kind of courage.