Wednesday, August 05, 2020

Johnson And Trump


There are many similarities between Boris Johnson and Donald Trump. But they both possess one glaring trait. Each man is singularly ill-equipped to do his job. In the case of Johnson, Rafael Behr writes,

he struggles with the job itself and with the wound to his ego from the discovery that governing is beyond his capabilities. He winces from that injury and tries to mask the strain in public with bluster. The giveaway is how much he relies on assertion that the challenge can be met with a sheer effort of will; how it can be beaten by national grit. “We must keep our discipline, we must be focused and we cannot be complacent,” he said in his most recent televised press conference.
In his head the plural pronoun “we” is a rallying cry, but in fact it is a crutch. He invites us all to carry the burden of responsibility because he is tired of carrying it himself. Evocations of blitz spirit were right for the first phase of the crisis, but events and the public have moved on. “We”, the nation, can exercise discretion and behave responsibly, but we cannot make the hard choices that land on a prime minister’s desk.

The ugly truth is that governing isn't easy:

Government is hard because it consists of constant, agonising judgments – picking between imperfect options, each with undesirable side-effects. Everyone who has reached any position of Westminster seniority, whether as a minister or civil servant, ends up awed by the relentless demand on a prime minister to make those calls. Everyone, that is, except Johnson, who appears to have been taken by surprise.
If it comes down to competing demands of, say, pub versus classroom, Johnson has to lean towards one at the expense or the other. But he has built his career in evasion of trade-offs. His mandate is fashioned from denial that they even exist. He would not be in power without Brexit, and his campaign for that cause was based on assertions of zero downside. His professed doctrine is cakeism (the belief in both having sweet things and eating them); anyone who queries the logic or tabulates the cost of ingredients is dismissed as a nay-saying nincompoop.
Johnson’s ideal communications strategy is not to tell people things they don’t want to hear and, when bad news comes knocking, to hide instead of answering the door. In Downing Street that approach is reinforced by the epic arrogance of his chief adviser, Dominic Cummings, whose working assumption in policymaking is that nearly everyone on the planet is stupider than him.

It's always been dangerous to assume that you're the smartest guy in the room. Because you're not.

Image: dw.com

6 comments:

Lorne said...

All of which goes to show, Owen, that the Americans do not have a monopoly on stupidity.

Owen Gray said...

I'm beginning to think that stupidity is more deadly than COVID, Lorne. And it's spreading like wildfire.

the salamander said...

.. I have a no touch - 10 foot pole rule re my observations on the pub politics of Great Britain.. it remains pristine, took no troutling ever. To me, God Save The Queen is a punk music anthem by the Sex Pistols.. Johnny Rotten nailed it forever.. he snarled it

Owen Gray said...

God will probably save the Queen, sal. I wonder, though, about Boris' long term future.

The Disaffected Lib said...

The good news. BoJo has managed to cause BBC to revive the "Spitting Image" franchise after a 24 year hiatus.

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-53662230

Owen Gray said...

Nobody does it like the Brits, Mound.