Wednesday, January 31, 2024

Trump And The World

Where Donald Trump goes, chaos follows. With that in mind, Max Boot speculates what foreign policy would be like in a second Trump term:

Every president but one since Franklin D. Roosevelt has believed that the United States should exercise preeminent international influence for its own good and that of the world. Trump is the lone exception. He is committed to an “America First” agenda — the same label embraced by the Nazi sympathizers and isolationists of the pre-Pearl Harbor period. He has nothing but scorn for the twin pillars of postwar U.S. foreign policy: free-trade pacts and security alliances.

In Trump’s first term, he did not manage to overturn more than 70 years of American global leadership, but he certainly undermined it. He pulled out of the Paris Climate Accords, the Trans-Pacific Partnership and the Iran nuclear accord. He tried to pull all U.S. forces out of Syria and about a third of them out of Germany. He temporarily blocked arms deliveries to Ukraine to coerce President Volodymyr Zelensky into helping him politically. He launched a pointless trade war with China that inflicted considerable costs on the U.S. economy.

It’s a safe bet Trump will not be appointing any moderates next time. He has vowed to purge apolitical civil servants — a.k.a. “Communists, Marxists, Racists, and Radical Left Thugs.” The Heritage Foundation is compiling long lists of MAGA loyalists to staff a Trump administration.

Thus, there would be little — aside from his own mental fog — to stop Trump from carrying out his isolationist agenda. According to Thierry Breton, a senior European Union official, Trump in 2020 told E.U. leaders “that if Europe is under attack we will never come to help you and to support you” and “NATO is dead, and we will leave, we will quit NATO.” Congress recently passed legislation to prevent a president from exiting NATO without congressional approval, but Trump could still make the alliance a dead letter by refusing to honor the Article 5 obligation to defend members under attack.

Trump would almost certainly cut off U.S. aid to Ukraine — as his followers in Congress are already attempting to do, at his behest. He says he would end the Ukraine war “in one day” by telling Zelensky that Ukraine would have “to make a deal.” Such a deal would presumably turn over at least 20 percent of Ukraine’s territory to Russian occupation while dictator Vladimir Putin readied his forces to take the rest. Zelensky called Trump’s talk “very dangerous,” but Trump is far more interested in courting Putin than Zelensky. (“I was the apple of his eye,” Trump recently boasted about his Kremlin pal.)

The leaders of some countries — e.g., Russia, North Korea, Hungary, Saudi Arabia — might be enthused about Trump returning to power, but it’s a safe bet that Mexico, America’s top trade partner, won’t be one of them. Trump has vowed to “carry out the largest domestic deportation operation in American history,” with most of those migrants presumably being sent south of the border over the opposition of the Mexican government. Trump, who talked in office about firing missiles at drug labs in Mexico, is also developing plans to unilaterally use military force against Mexican drug cartels — a move that no sovereign nation could tolerate.

Most elections are about domestic policy. Let's hope that American voters are interested in foreign policy. Under Trump, the world will not be a better place.

Image: Quartz

20 comments:

Graham said...

The world would benefit and be a better place if “some” people would contract a serious illness or encounter a very bad accident.
At some point I just don’t know how we can get around people like trump if they insist on getting in humanity’s way. Some, like trump, only exist because we allow them to. We, people, are too nice for our own good sometimes, too decent.
We need to be “taking out the garbage” more often.

Owen Gray said...

The legal system in the U.S.A. is beginning to do that, Graham.

Graham said...

Oh man. I hope so. I fear they may chicken out at some point or allow him time to be president again before they continue the many prosecutions. As well, even if they do find him guilty on any number of charges what will the penalty be? Will it be sufficient? What will his minions do and how will his followers react? I don’t know but I can foresee that the big sticks may have to be brought out.

Owen Gray said...

If there is any justice, Graham, Trump will spend the rest of his natural life in jail.

jrkrideau said...

He tried to pull all U.S. forces out of Syria and about a third of them out of Germany.

Boot seems to have missed the minor little fact that the US is illegally occupying parts of Syria, parts that hold Syria's best agricultural land and its oil resources. The oil, reportedly. is being exploited by a US company (Conoco?), shipped out through Turkey, and generally ends up in Israel.

I believe President Trump did order the withdrawal of troops from Syria. The Pentagon simply defied or lied to him.

I am not sure why Boot seems to think it is so important to keep US troops in Germany ~80 years after the war ended.

It's a long time to maintain occupation forces. If it was to oppose the Soviet Union, the USSR ceased to exist December 25, 1991.

Of course, the same occupation applies in Okinawa. I have seen reports that the Okinawans hate this. Something to do with pollution, rape, murder, and so on.

Trump's abrogation of the various treaties was egregious but it is not like other presidents have not done the same.

Under President Joe Biden's wise and benevolent leadership, the USA managed to precipitate a horrible proxy war with Russia, even worsen relationships with China—something I was amazed to see was possible—and is firmly supporting the Israeli genocide in Gaza which in turn has led to massive maritime disruptions as Anser Allah closes the Bab Al Mandab Straight to most shipping.

Actually, I believe Anser Allah is only interdicting US and UK and Israeli shipping and any ship doing business with Israel but almost all shipping companies will not take the risk of an accident or misidentification.

US and UK navel forces are now futzing around there making fools of themselves.

Trump, who talked in office about firing missiles at drug labs in Mexico, is also developing plans to unilaterally use military force against Mexican drug cartels — a move that no sovereign nation could tolerate.

Yes, I believe Granada, Panama, Iraq, Syria, Libya, Afghanistan, and a few other countries objected when Trump invaded them.

Trump was a horrible president and likely will be again, if elected. Biden has in many ways been even worse and, if re–elected will continue his stumble to perdition.

jrkrideau said...

He tried to pull all U.S. forces out of Syria and about a third of them out of Germany.

Boot seems to have missed the minor little fact that the US is illegally occupying parts of Syria, parts that hold Syria's best agricultural land and its oil resources. The oil, reportedly. is being exploited by a US company (Conoco?), shipped out through Turkey, and generally ends up in Israel.

I believe President Trump did order the withdrawal of troops from Syria. The Pentagon simply defied or lied to him.

I am not sure why Boot seems to think it is so important to keep US troops in Germany ~80 years after the war ended.

It's a long time to maintain occupation forces. If it was to oppose the Soviet Union, the USSR ceased to exist December 25, 1991.

Of course, the same occupation applies in Okinawa. I have seen reports that the Okinawans hate this. Something to do with pollution, rape, murder, and so on.

Trump's abrogation of the various treaties was egregious but it is not like other presidents have not done the same.

Under President Joe Biden's wise and benevolent leadership, the USA managed to precipitate a horrible proxy war with Russia, even worsen relationships with China—something I was amazed to see was possible—and is firmly supporting the Israeli genocide in Gaza which in turn has led to massive maritime disruptions as Anser Allah closes the Bab Al Mandab Straight to most shipping.

Actually, I believe Anser Allah is only interdicting US and UK and Israeli shipping and any ship doing business with Israel but almost all shipping companies will not take the risk of an accident or misidentification.

US and UK navel forces are now futzing around there making fools of themselves.

Trump, who talked in office about firing missiles at drug labs in Mexico, is also developing plans to unilaterally use military force against Mexican drug cartels — a move that no sovereign nation could tolerate.

Yes, I believe Granada, Panama, Iraq, Syria, Libya, Afghanistan, and a few other countries objected when Trump invaded them.

Trump was a horrible president and likely will be again, if elected. Biden has in many ways been even worse and, if re–elected will continue his stumble to perdition.

Owen Gray said...

For better or worse, the U.S. has been the dominant power in the world since the end of World War II, jrk. At least Biden has some understanding of the world. But, as his first Secretary of State said, Trump is a "fucking moron."

Anonymous said...

Unbelievable! Count on Max Boot for another pile of manure. I mean if you want to write about negative aspects of Trump’s presidency, there are many that can be legitimately criticized, particularly from a so-called “progressive”point of view. So why so much bullshit? Jrk has pointed out quite a few inaccuracies . “Preeminent influence for its own good and that of the world”. Boot seems disappointed Trump didn’t start a new illegal war somewhere. Millions slaughtered all across the globe. For what? From Vietnam to Panama to Granada to Central America to Iraq, Afghanistan to Libya to Serbia. And Boot thinks that Trump is the one sowing chaos? He’s right of course, but Trump’s destabilizing efforts are nothing compared to the mass nonsense of other “worthy” leaders. I got a good chuckle when he mentions Trump’s ‘mental fog’. The current occupier of the White House is demonstrably well ahead of Trump in that regard.
I will conclude by referring to an earlier comment made about this article. That comment clearly calls for the killing of a political opponent. We’ve just been too nice in allowing voters to decide who gets to choose our leaders. These political leaders we don’t like need to “have an accident”. To save Democracy! Just like they do in Russia, eh. And your comment on this call for assassination merits no pushback!? Only that “lawfare” should take care of things. Might / might not.And if that cheap trick doesn’t do it? Shame!
To boot, we’re now to believe that political killings are a “progressive” value? Can’t say I’m convinced of that yet.
Trump derangement syndrome is alive and thriving. At least that’s a fact! Left leaning haters are no better than the right wing ones! That’s an opinion. Mine.
BTW, I’ve never been a Trump fan, supporter, admirer or watcher of The Apprentice but he’s not worth turning that country into a total Banana Republic to avoid his maybe becoming President again. Mac

Owen Gray said...

Boot has always been on the right side of the spectrum, Mac -- which makes his observations particularly ironic.

Graham said...

Mac has misconstrued my post as meaning I am calling for trumps assassination a la putin style. I’m not. I would prefer he fall down an open manhole or be negatively affected by his overeating or love of fake tan products. However, I do not think we, the electorate, should put up with this type of behaviour from elected officials and we should not allow them to run again once found to have offended the rules of office or to serve the public. If one, such as trump, insists on abusing their position, abusing the office or leadership position they have, abusing the government and its workers then they should be forced to step down or be removed. No one before trump has been this abusive of the entire process and all that is decent in politics and government and just because some of his followers think this is just great is also not near enough reason to put up with it for a minute longer than absolutely necessary.
Yah yah, there have been other bad leaders in the US and elsewhere that have done many bad things and have cost the lives of many innocents. We are talking about trump though and just because there have been others does not give an excuse for trump.
trump has done his share of killing too and no one should buy the bunk about he didn’t start any wars or some such thing.
He has the present record for drone strikes and he removed the rules for the need to report such attacks as well as the details about them.
That trump first and foremost has tried to subvert democracy in his country, overturn a free and fair election and pressured election workers and officials is only part of the long list of what makes him unfit for any office and definitely unfit to lead the US.

Graham said...

Rational Conservatives everywhere are getting fed up with the trump style politics. In the US there has been a movement to get rid of trump for some time since even during his administration. Conservatives here in Canada too don’t like the pp or smith type of politics. They know that ultimately it isn’t going to get them and “us” to where we need to go. They know it will have a short shelf life or could possibly lead to much worse if it’s more ardent supporters have their way. This needs to be nipped in the bud. Unfortunately the pp’s, smith’s and trump’s of the political world gleefully stoke these fires and wilfully court the farside of politics knowing that there could very well be drastic negative consequences.
I’m sure these politicians will take all responsibility if or when it all goes sideways. /s

Owen Gray said...

That is precisely E.Jean Carroll's take on Trump, Graham. And she has dared to stand up to him.

jrkrideau said...

At least Biden has some understanding of the world.

As a member of a hegemonic superpower that has a distinguished record of coups, assassinations, invasions and general mopery and dopery. To be honest, the USA's knowledge of the rest of the world does not seem all impressive in the last few years. John Kerry, Mike Pompeo, and Anthony Blinken's records as US Secretaries of State are not distinguished. Nor has the records of their presidents.

The knowledge of Russian economy the coterie around Biden and whoever else was advising him was so good that the sweeping sanctions against Russia that were to "reduce the Ruble to Rubble" seems to have led to the IMF predicting ~2% economic growth for 2024 and a Europe in recession and sliding into depression. I am a bit reminded of Kennedy's "Best & Brightest".

Henry Kissinger may have been an evil, immoral, S.O.B but at least he had some knowledge of the world.

I think it is very clear that Biden has not grasped that the USA is not the dominant, single, superpower it was just after the desolution of the USSR. For that matter, I don't think most people in the USA have grasped this, especially those in the Washington bubble.

Raving warmongers like Lindsey Graham don't seem to realise that the USA no longer has any "willing" allies in the Middle East. Formerly stalwart ally, Saudi Arabia is co-operating with Russia in OPEC+ and selling oil to China in yuan not petro-dollars. Prince Mohammad bin Salman, reportedly, did not even pick up the phone when Biden called a few months.

Trump is completely ignorant of most of the world but he, at least before he began to even more mental deterioration, seemed to have some sense of national self-preservation similar to self-preservation, perhaps gained through mafia acquaintances. I don't think has the sense of invulnerability that Biden, his entourage and both Houses of Congress seem to have.

I imagine Trump does not have a patriotic bone in his body, not even the bone spurs. This is useful. I think he sees the wold in purely transactional terms and he is less likely to make grand, irrational, gestures for "the honour of the flag".

When one comes right down to it, neither man is even vaguely qualified to be town dogcatcher let alone the president of a major power. Possibly the difference is that Biden seems very much, to be someone's puppet while Trump is an uncontrollable two-year-old in a state of permanent temper-tantrum.

I tend to think the two-year-old is marginally less dangerous than the puppet.

Northern PoV said...

Thank you jrkriduea and Mac for your perceptive comments on the imbroglio.

Owen Gray said...

Double, double toil and trouble.
Fire burn and cauldron bubble.

Owen Gray said...

I simply disagree, jrk.

jrkrideau said...

I simply disagree, jrk.

Well given the general chaos, insanity and asininity in the USA, I may well be wrong. Come to think of it, I believe the technical scientistic term for the Current US political scene is "crap shoot".

Owen Gray said...

You could be right, jrk. I'm not noted for my ability to predict the future.

Owen Gray said...

I agree it should be nipped in the bud, Graham. But their many supporters make that difficult.

Owen Gray said...

There is a qualitative difference between the two men, jrk. Choices are never easy. But the baggage that comes with Trump makes the two options a relatively simple choice.