The events of the last three weeks have exposed the failure of multiple governments across Canada. At the root of it all, Susan Riley writes, is a failure of leadership:
We desperately need a confident leader, not just to stare down the incoherent bullies that have been tormenting the citizens of downtown Ottawa and wreaking economic havoc at our borders, but someone who could lead, or even inspire, a massive groundswell of hope and unity after the insurrection and the pandemic are over. Someone with a sharp mind, a kind heart and the courage to speak for the majority of reasonable, law-abiding Canadians whose voices have been drowned out lately by extremists and their enablers.
At the moment there appears to be no such person in sight:
NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh arose from his torpor last week to insist the prime minister “show leadership,” and “use the resources at his disposal” to end this thing immediately. He didn’t suggest what resources, but if the PM summoned the army to help move trucks (the only practical option, say some), Singh would be likely the first to denounce the intrusion on human rights.
Meanwhile, amid lame scoldings from Trudeau, the very late arrival Ontario Premier Doug Ford, the useless hand-wringing of mayors and police chiefs, the braying contempt of Conservative MPs concerned only for their own electorate prospects, an astonishing web of lies has risen almost unchallenged—from the basic to the truly bizarre.
Then there is Justin. He's been long on meetings and short on actions:
There is an air of privilege surrounding Trudeau, given his pedigree and his personal wealth (although he is probably no richer than that champion of the little guy, career politician Poilievre) and a lot of his critics hate him for it. And hate isn’t too strong a term.
The protesters have taken their inspiration from the American Alt Right:
The protest is no longer about truckers, or mandates, or even Bitcoin—a tangent that emerged last week. But it is definitely about harassing, intimidating, and trying to silence reporters covering the event. The convoy’s clamour for “freedom” apparently does not include freedom of the press, a requirement of every robust democracy. Is the bullying of individual reporters not deserving of outrage from some politician? Anyone? Not the careful “tut-tuts,” or scripted rebukes we have heard so far, but real conviction, real fire?
And who is speaking for Canadians who have played by the rules -- those who do not bathe in hot tubs in the streets?
And who, in all this, is passionately defending the majority of Canadians who are fully-vaccinated? Who speaks for those who lost parents, spouses, loved ones to this virus—or for the exhausted health-care workers so frequently lauded, so inadequately resourced, the teachers and parents and everyone else, just as fed up with life under COVID as the petulant, self-interested supporters of the protest? (And, as an aside, how many protesters benefited from CERB, or the other federal supports that helped mitigate the pain?)
Historians used to call Canada The Peaceable Kingdom. We are no longer that place. This is not a protest. This is sedition. Who will save our democracy?
Image: Sky News
16 comments:
These past 18 or so days should serve as a wake up call for Canadians to many things- including but certainly not limited to:
Systemic racism in police handling of protests or other civil disobedience the kid gloves treatment would most certainly have been gloves off/swat teams/tear gas to any minority who pulled the same stunts.
Insurrection- how vulnerable we are to insurrection- all that was missing was a storming of parliament while in session and who knows what could've happened.
Mainstreaming of conspiracy nonsense and misinformation about the pandemic
Influence of foreign based funding on actions in Canada
Vulnerable borders and access points.
Absolute failure of leadership at all levels of government- Prime Minister, Opposition, Provincial and Municipal, all failed to see this coming and respond coherently.
Mostly, the smugness that we are immune to this.
I agree, we are no longer the keeper of Peace that we thought we were. BC Waterboy
It's time to re-examine our myths, waterboy.
"Who will save our democracy"?
I shudder at the thought of our alternatives. Who indeed? Skippy?
I hope we're smart enough to save ourselves from Skippy, zoombats.
Sorry, we don't need a confident leader to stare down bullies and lead us to the post-pandemic promised land. Authoritarian regimes are built on such desires once the institutions of civil society have broken down.
Instead, our country needs a society that works even when mediocre people are in charge, and I'm seeing signs that's what we have. Ordinary residents of Ottawa, Kingston, Toronto and Windsor have successfully stared down big trucks and forced them to leave their communities, even as police stood by and asked the residents to move aside. Ordinary Canadians are telling their unaccountable and feckless police and politicians, "just watch us." There will be a reckoning once this is over.
Cap
Spontaneous groups of locals have stepped forward to protect our democracy in Kingston, Edmonton and Ottawa. In Ottawa, they even made the clownvoyers strip the decals off before sending them home. In all three cases our keystone cops forbade local resident resistance. The bobblehead bobbies were not too successful with that strategy either.
Hopefully , local residents will persevere to defeat both the cops and the robbers.
A hard-hitting piece that would incite some real soul-searching among our 'leaders', Owen, were they not so caught up in the abyss of their naval-gazing.
.. Thanks.. I’d like to see more of that type of observation moving to the front of the class. I have to grind through a lots of stuff that’s just plain time waster level. That’s why I don’t even bother to read Rex Murphy.. he’s long since dead to me. She has a provocative compelling perspective. Love how she gets right after it with her skewering. She basically cartoons the Usual Suspects with word & phrase. She also layers in an informed sensibility re Society’s state of mind & health. It’s quite refreshing
I agree, Cap. There is a reckoning coming. Ultimately, this will find its way back to those who vote.
Let's hope they take back their neighbourhoods, rumley.
As Cap says, Lorne, there is a reckoning coming.
Susan Riley is a professional, sal.
And the incredible thing is that we've paid the cops a King's ransom in overtime pay while they cheer on the thugs and hassle/arrest the good guys.
Win-win for the cops and thugs and lose-lose for the rest of us.
Now I hear we'll get Emergency Act but w/o the army. Sounds like the dystopia we call 2022.
We live in dark times, PoV.
Unfortunately the “Peaceable Kingdom” allowed the not-so-peaceable in as well.
UU
Indeed, UU.
Post a Comment