Thursday, May 18, 2023

Enforcing Ignorance

In the United States, there is a movement -- and it's gaining momentum -- to make students ignorant. Exhibit A is the state of Florida. Jennifer Rubin writes:

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, who earned two Ivy League degrees, has apparently decided that making Florida schools and universities the laughingstock of the country is good politics. The Republican already went after public school teachers with his “don’t say gay” bill, championed an effort to prevent instruction about history that might upset students (make that White students), and banned Advanced Placement classes in African American studies. Now, he has decided to shred the curriculums of Florida’s public universities, inviting students interested in unapproved subjects to go to California (!) or other states that don’t control what can and cannot be taught.

This week, he signed a bill banning state spending on diversity, equity and inclusion efforts in public universities. The Post reported: “These programs often assist colleges in increasing student and faculty diversity, which can apply to race and ethnicity, as well as sexual orientation, religion and socioeconomic status.”

Worse: “The law also forbids public colleges from offering general education courses — which are part of the required curriculum for all college students — that ‘distort significant historical events,’ teach ‘identity politics’ or are ‘based on theories that systemic racism, sexism, oppression, or privilege are inherent in the institutions of the United States and were created to maintain social, political, or economic inequities.’”

Who decides what “distorts”? How can the state prohibit instruction about, say, the consequences of Jim Crow in a U.S. history survey class? Well, that’s up to the regime DeSantis has installed. We now see the full extent of the governor’s authoritarian impulse to control independent sources of information and to eviscerate professional standards that provide the basis for challenging state action and abuse of power.

Thomas Jefferson believed that no democracy could survive without a well-educated citizenry. Obviously, Desantis is not interested in democracy. And he's put the people in place who share his objectives:

If newly installed University of Florida president and former Nebraska senator Ben Sasse had an ounce of integrity, he would resign in protest of this wholesale annihilation of academic freedom. (The Chronicle of Higher Education, however, reported recently that, a month into his tenure, “Sasse has made few public appearances and declined a number of interview requests from local media.” His obsequiousness to his partisan boss and contempt for academic independence should surprise no one.)

DeSantis is not alone in the assault on academic freedom; he is simply the highest-profile MAGA figure attempting to suppress freedom and dissent. The American Association of University Professors recently documented 57 bills in 23 states aimed at undermining academic freedom. The AAUP explained: “The current round of legislation reinforces a right-wing communication effort to attack public colleges and universities on the grounds that they are ideologically outside the mainstream, hostile to conservative views and focused on indoctrinating students into 'woke’ ideology.” The report added: “These bills are only one piece of a broader campaign to remake public higher education that includes Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis’ hostile takeover of the New College of Florida.”

Anti-democratic, nationalist movements have historically attacked universities as hotbeds of elite and foreign influence, seeking to bend instruction to the will of the state and turn academics into handmaidens of state propaganda. Right-wing pundits who have whined incessantly about the disfavored status of conservative academics (largely because of peer or student pressure) have had precious little to say about state-driven attacks against academic freedom from a petty autocrat. (Their caterwauling about political correctness on campus is the sort of projection and victimology that seeks to cast oppressors as victims and tyrants as saviors of Western culture.)

And DeSantis is making noises about running for president.

Image: The Washington Post

20 comments:

Cap said...

As Mark Twain said, "Every time you stop a school, you will have to build a jail. What you gain at one end you lose at the other. It's like feeding a dog on his own tail. It won't fatten the dog."

Of course, the US is Number One in the world in total number of people incarcerated, with more than 2 million prisoners nationwide. This number is equivalent to roughly 25% of the world's total prison population and leads to an incarceration rate of 629 people per 100,000—the highest in the world. Seems education is a long-standing problem.

As JS Mill observed, "Conservatives are not necessarily stupid, but most stupid people are conservatives." DeSantis is trying to grow the GOP base.

zoombats said...

"And DeSantis is making noises about running for president". This is the real story here. Imagine that this "exceptional"society here in the US republicans have everything riding on their choice for a leader to carry their message forward in 2024. The choice between a morally bankrupt sex offender and a malignant malcontent. The stupidity just boggles the mind but in all seriousness we should all be very alarmed at the prospects. The US fight for Democracy is an understatement. They are in a fight for their very lives. Our issues in Canada seem to pale by comparison.

Owen Gray said...

DeSantis knows exactly what he's doing, Cap. And that is why he's dangerous.

Owen Gray said...

This is an existential moment for the U.S., zoombats.

Trailblazer said...

Did it ever cross your mind De Santis long game is to be Trumps VP ?

TB

Owen Gray said...

He and others -- like Marjorie Taylor Greene -- appear to be auditioning for that role, TB.

zoombats said...

A toss up for sure but don't forget Kerri Lake.

Owen Gray said...

A rogues gallery, zoombats.

MoS said...

The rise of a genuinely fascist state in the midst of a world turning its back on democracy and embracing authoritarianism.

Putin, Kim, Bolsonaro, el Sisi, the House of Saud and the Gulf States, Erdogan, Hungary's Viktor Orban, Poland's Duda, Narendra Modi, Xi, a gaggle of US states and the GOP itself advance authoritarianism and menace democracy.

This fracturing and weakening of the global order could have disastrous consequences. Today we face truly existential challenges. Global warming is, as the name indicates, a global threat that requires a strong global consensus if we're to have any hope of achieving a soft landing.

Without a progressive restoration of the Liberal Party, Poilievre could become a Trump Mini-me. That Poilievre is even in the running speaks volumes of the decline in Liberal ranks under the leadership of Ignatieff and Trudeau Jr.

Owen Gray said...

We are marching backward, Mound -- flags waving.

Anonymous said...

According to US News & World Report's 2019 Best States Ranking, Florida had the best higher education system in the nation, and one of the best education systems overall. Maybe there is another side to this story. AN

Owen Gray said...

That survey was taken before DeSantis became governor in January 2019, AN. He's done a lot of damage in the last four years.

Trailblazer said...

Enforcing ignorance is an interesting title in this world where ignorance and lack of education is being used as a tool by the far right!
Higher education is often the first thing to be crushed in one way or another by repressive regimes.
I love the uneducated could well be the calling card of today's right wing politicians.



TB

Owen Gray said...

That is Mr. Trump's calling card, TB.

jrkrideau said...

I believe Priemier Danielle Smith has spoken favourably of DeSantis.

Owen Gray said...

The American Disease has crossed the border, TB.

Northern PoV said...

"This is an existential moment for the U.S."

I'd say that that moment* occurred a while ago, and it is sadly in the rearview mirror as we all follow the USA over the cliff.

*Bush/Gore was that moment.

Owen Gray said...

This has been a long time coming, PoV.

Murray B said...

Every time I see a DeSantis photo my mind fills in the image Alfred E Newman. In the photo leading off this post the similarity is even more pronounced. Too bad this cartoonish clown is so dangerous.
Murray B.

Owen Gray said...

Lots of politicians are cartoonish personages these days, Murray.