Friday, February 19, 2021

The Big Lie Migrates



Texans are freezing and in the dark -- because the state's power grid has failed catastrophically. Paul Krugman writes:

The underlying story of what happened in Texas appears to be fairly clear. Like many states, Texas has a partly deregulated electricity market, but deregulation has gone further there than elsewhere. In particular, unlike other states, Texas chose not to provide power companies with incentives to install reserve capacity to deal with possible emergencies. This made power cheaper in normal times, but left the system vulnerable when things went wrong.
Texas authorities also ignored warnings about the risks associated with extreme cold. After a 2011 cold snap left millions of Texans in the dark, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission urged the state to winterize its power plants with insulation, heat pipes and other measures. But Texas, which has deliberately cut its power grid off from the rest of the country precisely to exempt itself from federal regulation, only partially implemented the recommendations.

Texans aren't used to living through a deep freeze. But climate change is having its way:

The biggest problems appear to have come in the delivery of natural gas, which normally supplies most of the state’s winter electricity, as wellheads and pipelines froze. Nor was this merely a matter of the lights going out; people are freezing too, because many Texas homes have electric heat. Many of the homes without electrical heat rely on, yes, natural gas. We’re looking at enormous suffering and, probably, a significant death toll.
Instead of accepting responsibility, however, officials from Gov. Greg Abbott on down, backed by virtually the entire right-wing media complex, have chosen to lay the blame on green energy, especially wind power.
Now, it’s true that the state generates a lot of electricity from wind, although it’s a small fraction of the total. But that’s not because Texas — Texas! — is run by environmental crazies. It’s because these days wind turbines are a cost-effective energy source wherever there’s a lot of wind, and one thing Texas has is a lot of wind.
It’s also true that extreme cold forced some of the state’s insufficiently winterized wind turbines to shut down, but as I said, this was happening to Texas energy sources across the board, with the worst problems involving natural gas.

The Big Lie worked well for Republicans in Washington. Now The Lie has migrated south to Texas. Republicans there are hoping it will accomplish for them what it accomplished for the federal cousins.

Image: Dallas Morning News


10 comments:

Anonymous said...

They use wind turbines for power in Antarctica, so the problem wasn't the cold. The problem was that the power company was negligent and didn't winterize its equipment. As a result, West Texas wind turbines were out of service due to cold, but the warmer Gulf Coast turbines still worked and energy from wind was down only one percent from its normal contribution. These constant lies about renewable energy from politician in the pocket of fossil fuel companies is annoying, the media's uncritical reporting even more so.

The situation in Texas is reminiscent of the Enron years in California - unregulated energy companies scamming the hell out of consumers. People who paid $34 for electricity for all of Feb 2020 were hit will electrical bills of $2,800 for two day's use! I don't know how you can look at this and not see the signs of a failed state.

Cap

Owen Gray said...

Disaster Capitalism at its finest, Cap.

Lulymay said...

Texas is the home of Kinder-Morgan, you know the same folks Mr. Kinder and Mr. Morgan who were execs at Enron when the most vaunted accounting company "cooked" the books and caused a major financial issue in the US! The same Kinder-Morgan company that basically been allowed to take over natural gas distribution to customers here in BC. It doesn't seem to matter what these CEO's do, they regularly surface all over the place and it is the down-trodden consumer that continues to pay the price, both in service and in dollars.

Owen Gray said...

There's money to be made, Lulymay, when you can back people up against a wall.

The Disaffected Lib said...

While all eyes are on Texas, the foibles of Ted Cruz, etc. there's scant mention of the heatwave over Greenland in the 24 hr. darkness of the Arctic winter. Greenland is about 20C above normal in the pitch black. It's the very same anomaly that brought the deep freeze to the US south. Greece and Turkey are also enduring freezing conditions. It's the same deal - Hadley Cells and Rossby Waves.

Whenever some place gets hit by abnormal freezing conditions the first question should be, okay, so where's the heat. You'll find it but it's in the far north, sometimes well inside the Arctic Circle.

A few years ago, in late January/early February, road and hwy transporation came to a halt as Atlanta, Georgia entered a deep freeze. At the same time, residents of Barrow, Alaska basked in 64F conditions.

This is more than an interesting curiosity. It means that virtually every place in the Northern Hemisphere now must prepare for both extreme heat and extreme cold. We need a level of resilience an order of magnitude greater than anything we envisioned when most, nearly all of our critical infrastructure was designed and constructed.

The gently undulating jet streams of the Holocene brought us predictable weather patterns that travelled west to east. Now we have these Rossby Waves that carry tropical air far into the north and Arctic air far into the south - and just park there, sometimes for several days. This phenomenon drowned Calgary when a heavy rain storm that once would have deluged the city and then moved on, instead stayed put.

This is our new normal.

Owen Gray said...

It's our new normal, Mound. We need to build new infrastructure for the new normal -- and that project will require lots of labour.

zoombats said...

Wasn't Kinder Morgan into pipelines that one JT bought and is now flogging to the First Nations people of Alberta and British Columbia. Just saying... I could be mistaken.

jrkrideau said...

@ The Disaffected Lib

I noticed Abha in southwestern Saudi Arabia had snow. This is not usual.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8_4QQB18ZC8

Owen Gray said...

That's right, zoombats. Justin bought the pipeline from Kinder-Morgan.

Owen Gray said...

Hail and snow in Saudi Arabia, jrk? And some people still believe climate change is a hoax.