Sunday, December 02, 2018

Bush And Trump

No two men could be more different than George H.W. Bush and Donald J.Trump. Both were born into money, But that's the only similarity they shared. So how,  Max Boot asks, did we get from Bush to Trump? The answer is in the story of what became of the Republican Party. First there was Newt Gingrich:

The president was determined to reduce the growing deficits that he had inherited from Ronald Reagan — and that had grown larger still because of the need to bail out failing savings and loan associations. With the nation headed to war in Kuwait, he wanted to put America’s finances in order. The problem was that in 1988 he had foolishly promised, “Read my lips: No new taxes.” Bush knew he would pay a price for breaking his pledge, but he was determined to do so for the good of the country.
The No. 2 Republican in the House, Newt Gingrich of Georgia, initially appeared supportive of a spending deal that would have limited tax increases to levies on gasoline, alcohol and other products, avoiding income tax hikes. But when it came time to announce the agreement in the Rose Garden, Gingrich stalked out. Opposition from conservative Republicans and liberal Democrats doomed the deal, forcing a temporary government shutdown. Bush went back to the table, agreeing to a small increase in the top income tax rate, from 28 percent to 31 percent. (It had been 50 percent as recently as 1986.) House Republicans still rejected the deal, but this time there were enough Democratic votes to pass the compromise.
From a fiscal conservative’s perspective, the 1990 deal was a raging success. As Bruce Bartlett notes, “The final deal cut spending by $324 billion over five years and raised revenues by $159 billion.” It also put into place stringent rules mandating that any future tax cuts or spending increases would have to be offset by spending cuts or revenue increases. Within eight years, a $376 billion deficit had become a $113 billion surplus. Yet conservatives never forgave Bush for his apostasy.

And then there was Pat Buchanan, who ran against Bush in 1992:

Bush’s tax hike was also part of the rationale for Patrick J. Buchanan’s 1992 primary challenge, which proved more damaging than anyone had expected. The syndicated columnist won enough votes in New Hampshire (37.5 percent) to embarrass the incumbent and earn a prime-time slot at the Republican convention, where he gave his fiery “culture war” speech that repulsed moderates and independents. As Jeff Greenfield has noted, many of the themes Buchanan hit in 1992 were similar to Trump’s in 2016: He denounced threats to U.S. sovereignty, railed against globalization and multiculturalism, and called for “a new patriotism, where Americans begin to put the needs of Americans first.” 

In retrospect, it's easy to see that Buchanan was the precursor of Trump. One of Buchanan's most ardent backers was another Pat, the televangelist Pat Robertson. After meeting with one of Robertson's flock -- who refused to shake Bush's hand -- the president wrote this in his diary:

“They’re scary. They’re there for spooky, extraordinary right-winged reasons. They don’t care about Party. They don’t care about anything. . . . They could be Nazis, they could be Communists, they could be whatever. . . . They will destroy this party if they’re permitted to take over.” 

And that's exactly what they did.

Image: The Mercury News


Anonymous said...

Notwithstanding Boot's article, conservatives don't care about deficits except as a pretext to cut social programs. As Cheney said, "Reagan proved deficits don't matter." In any case, it wasn't Bush who balanced the budget, it was Clinton. Boot dishonestly gives one-term Bush credit for events "within eight years."

In fact, Bush Sr laid the foundation for Trump's overt racism. Bush's Willie Horton ad was a direct precursor of Trump's white nationalism.

Bush also pioneered the use of the presidential pardon to shield himself from impeachment and criminal liability. Bush preemptively pardoned Cap Weinberger who was facing six felony charges for his role in the Iran-Contra scandal. This effectively shut down the inquiry before it could examine Bush's role in the affair. Manafort, Corsi and Stone, amomg others, are counting on Trump to do the same.


Owen Gray said...

What you say is quite true, Cap. In fact, the corruption of the Republican Party began under Nixon and his dirty tricks unit. Stone, Manafort -- and particularly Lee Atwater -- were all dirty tricksters. They helped Bush win the presidency.

My point is that Trump is what the Republican Party hath wrought. They are at the root of the problem. That said, Bush was still a more decent human being than Trump.

Anonymous said...

I agree Owen. But best of a bad lot ain't sayin' much.


Owen Gray said...

It's hard to find a good lot these days, Cap.

The Mound of Sound said...

A marching Rogues Gallery. How could the Republicans not decay?

Owen Gray said...

The Party of Lincoln lost its way a long time ago, Mound. And Trump is the inevitable result.