Sunday, May 13, 2018

Despair Won't Get Us To Where We Want To Be


For some people, politics is all about finding a Messiah. Chris Hedges believes that approach leads to a dead end. Real political change begins with community:

No leader, no matter how talented and visionary, effectively defies power without a disciplined organizational foundation. The civil rights movement was no more embodied in Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. than the socialist movement was embodied in Eugene V. Debs. As the civil rights leader Ella Baker understood, the civil rights movement made King; King did not make the civil rights movement. We must focus on building new, radical movements that do not depend on foundation grants, a media platform or the Democratic Party or revolve around the cult of leadership. Otherwise, we will remain powerless. No leader, no matter how charismatic or courageous, will save us. We must save ourselves.

We have been mesmerized by the narcissism which permeates society. Its most ubiquitous icon is the selfie. But real political power doesn't begin with the self. It begins with the other. And that means several things:

It means receding into the landscape to build community organizations and relationships that for months, maybe years, will be unseen by mass culture. It means beginning where people are. It means listening. It means establishing credentials as a member of a community willing to make personal sacrifices for the well-being of others. It means being unassuming, humble and often unnamed and unrecognized. It means, as Cornel West said, not becoming “ontologically addicted to the camera.” It means, West went on, rejecting the “obsession with self as some kind of grand messianic gift to the world.”

And it has everything to do with education:

One of the most important aspects of organizing is grass-roots educational programs that teach people, by engaging them in dialogue, about the structures of corporate power and the nature of oppression. One cannot fight what one does not understand. 
The corporate state’s assault on education, and on journalism, is part of a concerted effort to keep us from examining corporate power and the ideologies, such as globalization and neoliberalism, that promote it. We are entranced by the tawdry, the salacious and the trivial.
The building of consciousness and mass organizations will not be quick. But these mass movements cannot become public until they are strong enough to carry out sustained actions, including civil disobedience and campaigns of noncooperation. The response by the state will be vicious. Without a dedicated and organized base we will not succeed.

Lately, I've had the feeling that Hedges has been drifting off into despair. But he seems to understand that the project he believes in will take time -- and that despair won't get us to where we want to be.

Image: Hemingway Solutions

6 comments:

the salamander said...

.. very insightful post.. very !

I sent a comment to Lorne this AM
and a couple to Mound yesterday..
I was trying to stir the pot
about getting religion out of politics
and getting politics far away from education
and take religion away from education

Was also on about community based politics
We have a fine MP & local lad - Nathaniel Erskine-Smith
and I like MP Michael Chong from Wellington County
The 'star' parachute MP's like Kellie Leitch truly bother me
and Doug Ford threatening the school curriculums
developed by actual educators ? Gaa !

There are so many examples of where
community based values 'worked'
and exemplars stepped up to bat
whether urban or rural..
and we have some fine Indy bloggers & tweeters
embedded in essentially every Canadian community

Owen Gray said...

These days -- particularly on the Right -- education is synonymous with indoctrination, Sal. The purpose of education is explanation -- of how things work, the world, the internal combustion engine, the brain, how we got here. And it should be the basis on which any society is built.

The Mound of Sound said...


These are issues we can only watch from the sidelines, Owen. If Hedges' prescription is doable at all, it won't be achieved by people of our vintage. It's stuff for the younger generation, their community, their activity. Do you believe that the young have a sense of this? Does it somehow resonate with them? Is the will to be found for another Occupy movement, one with more focus and muscle?

Reading this post goaded me into my archives to read old posts about the "Century of Revolution." It's going to take a day or two to let those earlier writings gel.

Owen Gray said...

My honest answer is I don't know, Mound. The young can disappoint. But, after all my years in the classroom I can also honestly report that they can pleasantly surprise. I learned a long time ago that we teachers suffer from a peculiar disase. We often think that we can predict a kid's future. We can't.

I'm continually heartened to meet former students who seem to have become happy, well rounded and successful. Many of them are now well into middle age and headed to retirement. I hope they are up to the challenge -- because you're right. The challenge is theirs.

the salamander said...

Mound hits a good point.. but ..
some things run in extended sequences.. small & large steps
History and knowledge carried over, evolving, growing
Best Practices.. refined.. fits n starts.. but progress

In the USA we currently see the reverse, complete collapse
and we saw and see it in Canada.. politically
The march away from fossil fuel is happening
the evolution to green industry as well
But the failures.. oh they hurt so much

I often use the analogy of Iceland
who''s tourism relies so much on whale watching
But they let Japan harpoon their whales for science
You have to be kidding... So we should follow suit..
trash our west coast fisheries for foreign owned pipelines.. right

How did our East Coast fisheries do ?
With the 'Worst Practices' ?

Owen Gray said...

Lessons from recent history -- not ancient history - are staring us in the face, Sal. But we refuse to see them.